My guess is you can't just screw the nut on with your fingers, I think you adjusted that valve when the lifters were not on the heal of the cam. If you put the motor on TDC with the #1 exhaust valve just closing, and the intake valve just starting to open you will see the dist. rotor is pointing at #4. That's when you adjust that cylinder. The lifters are always on the heal of the cam when it's firing. Then check overlap on #3 and adjust #2, then #4 TDC and adj #1, then #2 and adjust #3. You just can't have it not adjusted right if you do it that way. ANY OTHER WAY AND YOU"RE GUESSING!