Very well written Shawn. I work as a controller at a steel fabrication shop and can relate to what Shawn has said about the shop workers - going to the chiropractor is a monthly routine event. Broken toes from steel falling on the feet. Cuts, spinters in the eyes. Surgery on the hands and toes. Constant pain in the back, arms, and legs.
I have a BSB in accounting degree from the University of Minnesota and am a certified public accountant. My 35 years in public accounting, with the time pressures and the constant changes in working with a variety of businesses, and the wealth of knowledge required - generally accepted accounting principles, accounting software, income tax software, depreciation software, audit techniques, work paper documentaion, financial statement presentation, income tax laws for individuals, partnerships, and corporations has not been easy, but it has helped my thinking process and ability to solve problems and has broadened me as a person. I switched from public accounting to private industry 6 1/2 years ago to become controller at an ornamental iron and structural steel fabrication shop as their controller in full charge of the financial department. I love my job and hope to work for a few more years.
I would choose the education route (in my case, 7 years beyond high school), not only for a better job, but for the quality of life it can bring. Not everyone wants or can go to college, but do your best at whatever you do.