I've used both, they both rot equally well. Standard construction boards can last 3-5 years, treated a bit longer. The real difference comes from the carpet, use a poly, Indoor/outdoor type that doesn't hold water. Pontoon carpet I've been happy with. You could try to resin seal or Thompson's stuff, but in the end it seems the screw points provide the channel and rot the connection out. Curious, does this mean the cvz project is starting?